While in Toronto recently I was struck by the front-page headline in the Toronto Star: “Ontario Schools shelve libraries.”
In a controversial decision, the Windsor-Essex Catholic District School Board recently laid off all but four of its 39 librarians and is now dismantling all of its libraries. The board intends to revamp the use of space and use it more as student centres with computers and reference materials, or open it up for arts activities. This move has been attributed to two main factors: First, the ongoing shift to digital technologies resulting in declining use of books and journals by students. The second factor is cost savings, as that particular school board faces declining enrolment and an $8 – $10 million deficit in the next school year. So tough choices have to be made to avoid further financial losses.
Interestingly, that school board in Ontario is actually reflective of a broader trend across Canada. Although schools have not necessarily taken the drastic step of closing their libraries, very few are still staffed with a qualified librarian. To put things in perspective, understand that we have three full-time librarians here at LCC to staff our Junior and Senior libraries. In the public school system in the province of Nova Scotia there are none, there are only three left in all of New Brunswick, and numbers have declined notably in Alberta and BC’s public school systems as well. In Ontario primary schools, only 12% have full-time librarians.
In the face of this discouraging trend in Canada, studies have actually shown a strong relationship between professionally-staffed libraries and student achievement in school, including better scores on standardized tests (as much as 8%) and much more positive attitudes toward reading.
Meanwhile in Europe in the past decade, the trend has been the opposite of what’s happening in Canada. Europeans are investing in and developing libraries as a force to improve education. So in the Canadian context, I guess here at LCC we are “countercultural” relative to our Canadian counterparts and have aligned ourselves more with Europeans.
Although we have been proactive with the use of digital media at LCC, we also believe in the value of the book. We support the importance of the library as an information centre and oasis of calm in a noisy world. In the library students can read quietly, reflect and harvest the seeds of their creativity.
We have a reading week in our Junior School and our LCC Reads initiative in Middle/Senior School remains an important and interesting activity in our annual calendar. As the broader debate on libraries continues, one thing is for sure, the level of literacy that each student develops during their time at LCC will likely define much of their success in university studies and likely in professional life. So despite a host of other attractive options in their busy lives, young people need to make time to read; it will definitely make a difference in their futures.
Keeping our LCC libraries open is our priority and we will continue to actively support the development of literacy across all grades. By the way, our annual Book Fair is around the corner: May 26-27. Be sure to pick up a copy of the new LCC Reads book, The Heart Specialist. I hope you find something there that tweaks your interest. –Chris Shannon, Headmaster
Thanks for seeing the value of Libraries and Librarians. They have made such a impact on my children’s learning and our family’s quality of life. Long live books!
I know that blog responses should be short but this is a topic close to my heart….Mr. Shannon is to be congratulated for recognizing the value of libraries. I, also, deplore the short-sighted actions of certain school boards across the country whose libraries are being closed. These are some of my reasons:
1. The library is an oasis of peace and quiet, a place where students can escape the hustle and bustle and noise of the school, a place where they can find calm and sanctuary. Where else in a school is this available?
2. Studies have proven that test scores of students who go to schools with libraries and librarians are significantly higher than students who do not have access to these resources.
3. In this “Information Age” we are drowning in facts and figures. When does this data translate into knowledge and wisdom? Librarians are experts in finding information and it is our pleasure here at LCC to teach research skills and help our students find and evaluate information and go beyond the superficial. The databases provided by the library i.e. ELibrary, Eureka, etc. are top notch and the best available to high school students.
4. Electronic resources are one source of information but they are not the only source. Books will continue to play a very valuable role in a well-educated person’s life. Books, if they are current, interesting, and pertinent, compete favourably with digital information and are often preferred by savvy students. Paper, after all, has proven to be a very enduring medium and will continue to be so. Who remembers microfilm, and VHS?
5. Reading a novel improves reading skills, deepens understanding of self and others, gives pleasure, etc. It also trains children to sit still and develops calmness, patience and peace of mind, countering the tendency to hyper-activity that constant clicking, texting and video games encourage.
6. It is not only LCC that is following the European model of supporting libraries. The province of Quebec, after lagging behind the rest of the country for many years, has recognized the importance of libraries and is now proud to state that nearly all schools in the province have a library and these libraries are staffed by a person responsible for the collection (regrettably not necessarily a trained librarian).
7. Reading must be encouraged and promoted both one-on-one and collectively. Who better than a librarian who has read many of the books in the library to recommend the right book for your child?
Promoting reading and the love of books and literature are the goals of all the activities planned by the LCC library. Inviting authors to the school, Reading Week, reading games, LCC Reads and Book Fair all focus on reading in fun and exciting ways.
Please join us at the Book Fair on May 26 and 27 to show your support of reading and literacy and to ensure that your children are prepared for their summer reading. Remember “Reading Springs the Imagination”.
Maria Varvarikos
Head Librarian